JMS or SOAP

[karthik_rangaraju3]

Hi All,

- We are integrating XI and TIBCO. Now we have two ways of doing it. Using JMS or Using SOAP. Now out of the two, what is recommended.

- We have to use Synchronous messaging in our integration, Does JMS support it now?

Thanks for your help in advance,

Karthik

[Former Member · Accepted solution]

Hi Karthik,

Check these similar threads on XI and TIBCO:

Also check this article:

https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/5474f19e-0701-0010-4eaa-97c4f78d...

Regards,

Subhasha Ranjan

[karthik_rangaraju3 · Accepted solution]

Between JMS and SOAP approach, which is the industry recommended.

Thanks

[Former Member · Accepted solution]

HI Karthik,

As per my understanding in case of synchronous SOAP will be better option, else go for JMS.

Regards,

Subahsha Ranjan

[prateek · Accepted solution]

Hi Karthik,

The choice between SOAP and JMS depends upon the client requirement. So according to their usage in industry, both could be supported.

Refer to this

Some comparison of JMS and SOAP message structures

Regards,

Prateek

[prateek]

Hi Karthik,

From SAP note 856346:

2.3. Question: Which XI quality of services (QoS for short) are supported?

Answer: XI recognizes the QoS Best Effort (BE, synchronous), Exactly Once (EO, asynchronous) and Exactly Once In Order (EOIO, asynchronous). The JMS Adapter supports EO and EOIO, since JMS is itself an asynchronous message service.

Thus, JMS only supports synchronous scenario. So in my opinion u should go for SOAP adapter.

For sync/Async scenario using JMS,

/people/venkataramanan.parameswaran/blog/2007/01/18/syncasync-communication-in-jms-adapter-without-bpm-sp19

Regards,

Prateek