which adapter should use SOAP or http?

[abhay_aggarwal]

Hi SDners,

I have a one scenario in which I have to integrate our ECC system to our company intranet site. for this scenario what approch I have to take?

Please suggest

Regards

[Former Member · Accepted solution]

Hello Folk,

You should go either SOAP / HTTP Adapter as per your client requirment

the basic thing is like SOAP is the best while we go for the webservices devlopment.

HTTP is also good but some times it is not secure and reliable when compare to SOAP

Can you tell me the business scenario / requirment then i can suggest the Adapter , any how you may find the better inputs in

SDN Forum.... search .....

Regards,

Ravi.

[abhay_aggarwal · Accepted solution]

Hi ,

My scenario is like this .

I have to inegrate the one website to Our ECC system.

this site is for are company in which our company employee submit their leaves and allowance and advance pay related to salary.so we to send this data to ECC which will be updated in ECC table frm their BI team make some rports for employess.

Regards

[prateek · Accepted solution]

You may use both adapters. Go with HTTP to start with and it should satisfy all your requirements.

Regards,

Prateek

[abhay_aggarwal · Accepted solution]

Hi Prateek,

As I understand If I will got for SOAP adapter we don't have make any RFC connection between

SOAP>>>XI

but if we go for HTTP adapter then which type of conection we have to make?

Can you plz tell me steps which are req to create this scenario?

Regards

[Former Member]

Hi Abhay,

I think you can use HTTP adapter in your case , there will be two modes url and http destination in channel configuration ,

you can choose to create HTTP Destination mode and create a RFC Destination in sm59

(HTTP Type=G).Here you mention your internal site connection details like parameter for

connections , user and password etc .By doing so, you can test the connection from XI to the url.

You can test the rfc connection in the test connection tab in RFC destination.If connection test

is ok then you can use this http destination in you http channel.

But if you question is to compare HTTP or SOAP , then as suggested above a simple search will

give best answers to your questions.

Regards,

Srinivas

[Former Member]

Hi,

check with the technology inwhich intranet is developed...so based on that you can go for the options...

I think the application can handle Webservices ..so better use SOAP adapter rather than HTTP as Http adapter have some limitations ..

HTH

Rajesh

[rajasekhar_reddy14]

SEARCH IN SDN,YOU WILL FIND MANY POSTS ON SAME DISCUSSION